Polls

Loading ...

Polls Archive

Sahuaro

8

Walden Grove

51

Oct 6 / Football
Sahuaro

1

Canyon del Oro

3

Oct 5 / Girls Volleyball

Team Edward or Team Jacob?

Tatum Crawford and Reporter

August 25, 2023

Twilight: the vampire-romance series that stars a teenage girl named Bella Swan, a vampire named Edward Cullen, and a wolf shape-shifter named Jacob Black. This series has ignited a heated debate between two sides that still continue to spark: Team Edward or Team Jacob?

Edward Cullen, the vampire with a mysterious demeanor, has caught many viewers’ hearts, and not only for Bella Swan. His chivalry and sacrificial love make him a great candidate for Bella. He embodies the classic gentlemen archetype, often displaying chivalry and grace. His protective acts towards Bella are seen as selfless, as he always puts her safety over his well-being. Not only is he protective, but he is also committed. Edward’s commitment to Bella highlights his willingness to make sacrifices for his loved ones. His decision to leave Bella in New Moon is a testament to his desire to protect her from not only himself, but to other dangers of his own world.

Jacob Black, the shape-shifter werewolf, has also captured positive feelings from viewers. However, with his manipulative behavior and boundary issues, is he really the best for Bella? Some people argue that Jacob’s behavior can be seen as controlling, particularly in Eclipse. His attempts to charm her away from Edward while she’s in a vulnerable state can be seen as manipulative and disrespectful of her feelings.

So who is best for Bella? There are some qualities from the two that can help validate your choices. Because of Jacob’s manipulative tactics and boundary issues, I think Bella would be better off without him, but they could still remain friends. However, because of Edward’s commitment and desire to protect Bella, I believe he would be the best choice for her, and they would look great together. Ultimately, the choice between Team Edward or Team Jacob is a personal choice, but for me, there is an obvious choice of who is better for Bella.

About the Contributors

Tatum Crawford, Editor

Senior, Tatum Crawford, joined The Paper Cut last year to grow her interpersonal and writing skills. Tatum enjoys traveling and sightseeing, especially with her mom, who she is very close to as it was just her and her mom for 12 years. Her ideal places to visit are Milan and Florence, where she found an appreciation for the food and art. She enjoys art museums, her favorite ones being the Louvre and the Uffizi Gallery. Tatum plays many games, especially Animal Crossing and Legend Of Zelda. She adores taking pictures; she has over 30,000 photos on her phone - most of them being travel and cat photos. Family is also super important to Tatum. She loves visiting her family in Mississippi and spending time with them. She has family scattered all around the world, including eighteen siblings. She's only met about four so far but would be interested in meeting the rest. Out of all of them, she is the youngest, as they are in their late twenties. When she graduates, Tatum wants to move to Seattle with her older sister to attend her dream college - the University of Washington. Her other option is NAU. Regardless of where she goes, she wants to study medicine.

Reporter, Reporter

Surenady Payne, a sophomore, aspires to pursue a career as a lawyer or surgeon in the future, driven by a long-standing focus on professional development since the age of 7. Motivated by a desire to advocate for those in need, she is embarking on her inaugural year with The Paper Cut to convey new experiences and events unfolding at Sahuaro. Exhibiting a fervent passion for writing, she aims to cast light on daily observations and offer insight into a range of subjects, particularly social issues and influential figures within her community. As the eldest of 5 children, she embraces the role of an older sister, finding fulfillment in guiding and witnessing the growth of her younger siblings. Surenady has a diverse music taste and enjoys various genres, but she particularly likes rap, hip hop, country, and rock 'n' roll. Her music taste is an important part of her self-expression. Similarly, her fashion sense is diverse, and she enjoys experimenting with unique styles that reflect her individuality.